agent-chat-ux

name: agent-chat-ux
version: 1.5.2
author: Charles Sears
description: Multi-agent UX for OpenClaw Control UI — agent selector, per-agent sessions, session history viewer with search, agent-filtered Sessions tab with friendly names, Create Agent wizard, emoji picker, and backend agent CRUD.

⚠️ Security & Transparency Notes

Before applying this skill's patches, be aware of the following:

Credential Access (agents.wizard)

The AI Wizard backend (agents.wizard RPC) calls the configured model provider API directly via HTTP. To do this it needs an API key. It resolves credentials in this exact order:

1. Default config auth — uses it if the resolved mode is api-key (most common)
2. Auth profile store — searches for the first api_key-type profile matching the provider. Reads only provider and type fields to find it; does not log or return values.
3. Environment variable — ANTHROPIC_API_KEY or OPENAI_API_KEY as a last resort

If you don't want the wizard reading your auth store, set ANTHROPIC_API_KEY in your environment and ensure your default auth profile is already api-key mode — step 2 is skipped entirely in that case.

External API Calls

agents.wizard makes a single HTTP POST to:

• https://api.anthropic.com/v1/messages (Anthropic models)
• https://api.openai.com/v1/chat/completions (OpenAI-compatible models)

No other outbound calls. The call carries your user-supplied description and nothing else from your system.

Patch Scope

These patches modify only agent-related files:

Each patch is scoped to a single concern. If any patch file modifies more than the files listed above, stop — you have an outdated copy.

LLM Output Validation

Wizard model output is parsed as JSON and validated before use:

• Must be a JSON object with name (string), emoji (string), soul (string)
• name is capped at 100 characters, emoji at 10
• soul must be ≥ 20 characters
• Empty or non-JSON responses are rejected with a user-visible error — nothing is auto-created

Source Code Modification

This skill applies git apply patches against ~/openclaw and requires a UI + gateway rebuild. Changes are persistent. Always backup before patching:

cd ~/openclaw && git stash  # or git branch backup/pre-agent-ux

What This Skill Adds

1. Agent Selector Dropdown in Chat Header

When multiple agents are configured, a dropdown appears left of the session dropdown in the chat header. Selecting an agent switches to that agent's most recent session (or falls back to a fresh webchat key for that agent). The session dropdown automatically filters to show only sessions belonging to the selected agent.

2. Per-Agent Session Filtering (Sorted Newest First)

Sessions are now scoped to the active agent and sorted newest-first. No more mixing other agents' cron jobs and subagent sessions into the current chat's session picker.

3. + New Session Button in Chat Header

A + icon button sits right of the session dropdown, allowing new sessions to be started without typing /new.

4. Create Agent Panel (Manual + AI Wizard)

The Agents tab gains a + Create Agent button that expands a panel with two modes:

Manual mode:

• Agent name
• Workspace path (auto-generated from name if left blank)
• Emoji picker (see below)

AI Wizard mode:

• Describe the agent in plain English
• Click "Generate Agent" — AI generates name, emoji, and full SOUL.md
• Review the preview, then click "✅ Create This Agent"

After creation, the agents list and config form are both refreshed automatically — no "not found in config" error, no manual reload needed.

5. Emoji Picker Dropdown

The emoji field in Create Agent and Edit Agent forms is a dropdown with 103 curated emojis grouped into 5 categories (Tech & AI, People & Roles, Animals, Nature & Elements, Objects & Symbols), each showing the emoji and its name. A large live preview shows the selected emoji next to the dropdown.

6. Edit Agent Inline (Agents Overview)

The Agents Overview card now shows editable inputs directly — no toggle needed:

• Name, Emoji (dropdown, 103 emojis), Workspace are always editable
• Changes activate the bottom Save button — no separate inline Save/Cancel
• Emoji is saved as - Emoji: in IDENTITY.md (last-wins override of creation value); identity cache is evicted after save so changes appear immediately
• Edit uses the emoji param of agents.update (not avatar) so the correct IDENTITY.md key is written

7. Delete Agent

• 🗑️ Delete button appears in the Overview header for non-default agents
• Inline confirmation dialog before deletion; hidden for the main/default agent

8. Agent-Specific Cron Stats

The Scheduler card on the Cron Jobs tab previously showed global gateway stats (total job count, global next wake). Now:

• Jobs → count of cron jobs targeting this agent only
• Next wake → earliest nextRunAtMs across this agent's jobs (n/a if no jobs)
• Subtitle → "Agent cron scheduling status." (was "Gateway cron status.") This means agents with no crons correctly show Jobs: 0 / Next wake: n/a.

9. Agents Tab — Model Selector Cleanup

• Removed the redundant read-only "Primary Model" row from the Overview grid (it's already editable in the Model Selection section below)
• Fallback models converted from a free-text comma-separated input to a proper <select multiple> using the same full model catalog as the primary selector
• Added spacing and clear labels between primary and fallback fields
• Small hint "(hold Ctrl/⌘ to select multiple)" on the fallback selector

10. Backend — agents.create / agents.update / agents.delete / agents.wizard

New RPC handlers wired into the gateway:

Auth fix in agents.wizard: Raw HTTP calls to the model API require an api_key token, not an OAuth/bearer token. The wizard now falls back to an explicit api_key profile (or ANTHROPIC_API_KEY env var) when the default resolved auth mode is oauth or token.

11. Session History Viewer (v1.4.0)

A modal overlay accessible from the Sessions tab that displays full conversation history for any session:

• Agent dropdown filter — scope sessions by agent
• Session dropdown — pick a session to view (filtered by agent)
• Search bar — debounced full-text search across message content (case-insensitive)
• Role filter chips — All / User / Assistant / System / Tool
• Message timeline — role icons (👤/🤖/⚙️/🔧), timestamps, and message text
• Pagination — "Load More" with count display (100 messages per page)
• Click "History" button on any row in the Sessions tab to open

12. Sessions Tab Overhaul (v1.4.0)

The Sessions tab now provides a unified multi-agent experience:

• Agent filter dropdown — filter sessions by agent (populated from agents.list)
• Friendly session names — "Main Session", "Cron: pipedream-token-refresh", "discord:#bot-chat" instead of raw keys like agent:main:cron:cc63fdb3-...
• Agent identity column — shows agent emoji + identity name (e.g. "🤖 Assistant") using identity.name → name → id fallback chain
• Raw key shown as subtitle — full technical key displayed in smaller muted monospace text below the friendly name
• Label column removed — redundant since the friendly name already incorporates label/displayName
• CSS grid layout — proper column alignment using grid-template-columns with proportional widths; headers align precisely with data
• Empty state — clear message when an agent has no sessions
• Session count — total/filtered count shown in the store info line
• History button pre-selects — clicking History on a row opens the modal with agent and session already selected, loading history immediately

13. Backend — sessions.history RPC (v1.4.0)

New RPC handler that reads full JSONL transcript files:

Returns {key, sessionId, agentId, total, offset, items[{role, text, timestamp}]}.

14. Auth Mode Badge on Every Assistant Message (v1.5.0 / v1.5.1)

A small pill badge appears on every assistant message group showing which auth method was used:

How it works:

1. After each final chat event, the UI calls auth.status RPC
2. The RPC reads lastGood from auth-profiles.json and returns {profileId, mode}
3. chatAuthMode state is updated and passed as fallbackAuthMode to all message groups
4. Messages with a specific _authProfileId (from the run pipeline) use that; all others fall back to chatAuthMode
5. renderAuthBadge() handles both profileId strings (e.g. anthropic:manual) and __mode:oauth shorthand

This ensures every assistant message shows a badge, including tool-use messages and messages from autonomous loops.

"Up to Date" pill: The gateway version header now shows "Up to Date" in a styled pill matching the Version and Health pills (green dot + rounded backdrop).

15. Pipedream Tab Refreshes on Agent Switch (v1.5.0)

Previously, switching agents while on the Pipedream sub-tab kept showing the previous agent's data. Now onSelectAgent reloads Pipedream (and Zapier) state when their respective sub-tabs are active. Same fix applied to Zapier tab.

16. OAuth-First Auth Priority Enforcement (v1.5.1)

The auth profile candidate list is now sorted so token/oauth type profiles always come before api_key profiles, regardless of the order returned by resolveAuthProfileOrder. This guarantees OAuth is tried first for Anthropic even if the profile resolution system silently skips it.

// In pi-embedded-runner/run.ts — applied after resolveAuthProfileOrder()
const sortedProfileOrder = [...profileOrder].sort((a, b) => {
  const typeA = authStore.profiles[a]?.type ?? "api_key";
  const typeB = authStore.profiles[b]?.type ?? "api_key";
  const rank = (t: string) => (t === "token" || t === "oauth" ? 0 : 1);
  return rank(typeA) - rank(typeB);
});

Files Changed

UI Design & Styling Reference

This section documents the UI design decisions for anyone installing or extending this skill.

Sessions Tab Layout

Uses CSS grid (display: grid) instead of the default OpenClaw .table flex layout for precise column alignment:

.sessions-grid {
  grid-template-columns: 2fr 1.2fr 0.6fr 0.8fr 1fr 0.8fr 0.8fr auto;
  /* Session | Agent | Kind | Updated | Tokens | Thinking | Reasoning | Actions */
}

• Headers: 12px uppercase, letter-spacing 0.5px, var(--text-muted) color, bottom border
• Rows: display: contents for grid participation, subtle bottom border, hover highlight at 2% white opacity
• Session name cell: Friendly name as bold link (var(--accent, #6366f1)), raw key below in 11px muted monospace at 50% opacity
• Agent column: 13px text, emoji + identity name (e.g. "🤖 Assistant")
• Selects: max-width: 100px to prevent overflow

Session History Modal

Dark overlay modal with the following structure:

┌──────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│  Session History                            [✕]  │
│  [Agent ▼]  [Session ▼]                         │
│  [🔍 Search...]  [All] [User] [Asst] [Sys] [Tool]│
│  ─────────────────────────────────────────────── │
│  👤 User · Feb 23, 10:23 AM                     │
│  Hello, can you help me?                         │
│  ─────────────────────────────────────────────── │
│  🤖 Assistant · Feb 23, 10:23 AM                │
│  Of course! What do you need?                    │
│  ─────────────────────────────────────────────── │
│          [Load More ↓]  Showing 100 of 342       │
└──────────────────────────────────────────────────┘

Key CSS variables used:

• var(--bg-card, #1a1a2e) — modal background
• var(--border, #333) — borders
• var(--accent, #6366f1) — user role color, active chip
• var(--text, #e0e0e0) — message text
• var(--border-subtle, rgba(255,255,255,0.06)) — message separators

Role colors:

Role icons: 👤 User, 🤖 Assistant, ⚙️ System, 🔧 Tool, 💬 Other

Session Name Resolution

The friendly name fallback chain:

1. row.label (user-set label)
2. row.displayName (server-computed, e.g. "discord:#bot-chat")
3. Smart key parsing:
   • *:main → "Main Session"
   • *:cron:*:run:* → "Cron Run"
   • *:cron:* → "Cron Job"
   • *:subagent:* → "Subagent"
   • *:openai:* → "OpenAI Session"
   • *:<channel>:direct:<id> → "Channel · id"
   • *:<channel>:group:* → "Channel Group"
4. Raw key as fallback

Agent Identity Resolution

For the Agent column and dropdowns:

1. agent.identity.name (from IDENTITY.md — e.g. "Assistant")
2. agent.name (from config — e.g. "main")
3. agent.id (raw identifier)

Emoji: agent.identity.emoji with "🤖" as fallback.

Chat Dropdown

The session dropdown in the chat header shows all sessions for the selected agent (no time filter). Previously limited to sessions active within 120 minutes, which hid older Discord channels and other sessions.

Installation

This skill requires patching OpenClaw source files and a UI + gateway rebuild.

Prerequisites

• OpenClaw source at ~/openclaw (fork or local clone)
• pnpm installed (npm install -g pnpm)
• Node.js 20+

Step 1: Apply patches

cd ~/openclaw

git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/schema-agents.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/agents-view.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/agents-utils.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/agents-panels-cron.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/app-render-helpers.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/app-render.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/app-main.txt
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/server-agents.txt

If any patch fails due to upstream drift, apply manually using the patch file as a line-by-line reference.

Step 1b: Apply v1.4.0 patches (Session History + Sessions Tab Overhaul)

cd ~/openclaw

# Backend: sessions.history RPC
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.4.0/patch-01-sessions-history-rpc.txt

# Sessions tab: friendly names, agent column, agent filter
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.4.0/patch-02-sessions-tab-overhaul.txt

# App state + render wiring for history modal
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.4.0/patch-03-app-wiring.txt

# New file: session history modal component
cp ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.4.0/patch-04-sessions-history-modal.ts \
   ui/src/ui/views/sessions-history-modal.ts

# Chat dropdown: show all sessions (remove 120min active filter)
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.4.0/patch-05-chat-sessions-all.txt

Step 1c: Apply v1.5.0 patches (Auth badge + Pipedream agent switch fix)

cd ~/openclaw

# Auth badge (auth.status RPC + per-message badge on all assistant groups)
# Also includes: OAuth-first sort, "Up to Date" pill styling
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.5.0/patch-auth-badge.txt

# Pipedream/Zapier tab refresh on agent switch + chatAuthMode wiring to chat view
git apply ~/.openclaw/workspace/skills/agent-chat-ux/references/v1.5.0/patch-pipedream-agent-switch.txt

Step 2: Rebuild UI

cd ~/openclaw
pnpm ui:build

Step 3: Rebuild gateway (for backend agent methods)

cd ~/openclaw
pnpm build

Step 4: Restart gateway

openclaw gateway restart

Step 5: Verify

1. Open Control UI at http://localhost:18789
2. Chat tab — agent dropdown appears left of session dropdown (if >1 agent configured); + button appears right of session dropdown
3. Agents tab — "+ Create Agent" button with Manual and AI Wizard modes
4. Agents → Overview → Model Selection — fallback is now a multi-select dropdown
5. Create an agent with the AI Wizard — should generate cleanly and appear in the list with no "not found" error
6. Agents → Overview — Name, Emoji, Workspace are editable directly; Save button at bottom activates on any change
7. Change an agent's emoji — after Save it should persist (not revert to the original creation emoji)
8. Agents → Cron Jobs — agents with no cron jobs show Jobs: 0 / Next wake: n/a (not the global gateway count)
9. Sessions tab — sessions show friendly names (e.g. "Main Session") with agent emoji+name column; agent filter dropdown works
10. Sessions tab → History button — opens modal with conversation history, search, and role filter chips
11. History modal → Agent filter — changing agent filters the session dropdown; selecting a session loads its messages
12. Chat dropdown — session dropdown shows ALL sessions for the selected agent (including older Discord channels, OpenAI sessions, etc. — not just recent ones)

Usage

Chat: Switching Agents & Sessions

• Agent dropdown (left of session): picks the agent; session list updates to show only that agent's sessions
• Session dropdown: switches between existing conversations for the selected agent, newest first
• + button: starts a new session for the current agent (same as /new)

Agents: Create Agent

1. Click + Create Agent
2. Manual: enter name, workspace, pick emoji → "Create Agent"
3. AI Wizard: describe the agent → "Generate Agent" → review preview → "✅ Create This Agent"

Agents: Fallback Models

In Model Selection:

• Primary model — single dropdown
• Fallback models — multi-select (Ctrl/⌘ + click for multiple); these are retried in order when the primary model fails (rate limit, context overflow, etc.)

Sessions: Viewing History

1. Go to Sessions tab
2. Optionally filter by agent using the Agent dropdown
3. Click History on any session row
4. The modal opens with the full conversation
5. Search — type to search across all messages (300ms debounce)
6. Role chips — click All/User/Assistant/System/Tool to filter by role
7. Load More — pagination loads 100 messages at a time

Sessions: Agent-Filtered View

The Sessions tab now shows:

• Session column — friendly name with raw key as subtitle
• Agent column — emoji + name from agent identity
• Agent filter — dropdown at top to scope the view per-agent

Architecture Notes

Session Key Format

agent:<agentId>:<rest> — the agent selector reads parseAgentSessionKey(state.sessionKey).agentId to determine the active agent and filters the session list accordingly.

Config Refresh After Creation

After agents.create succeeds, the UI calls both agents.list (to update the sidebar) and loadConfig (to refresh configForm). Without the loadConfig call, selecting the new agent would show "not found in config" because the config form was stale.

Wizard Auth Resolution

agents.wizard makes a direct HTTP call to the model provider API. Raw HTTP calls require an api_key type credential — not an OAuth bearer token. The resolution order is:

1. Default resolveApiKeyForProvider result (used if mode is api-key)
2. First api_key-type profile in the auth store for the provider
3. ANTHROPIC_API_KEY / OPENAI_API_KEY env var directly

This mirrors the same pattern used in enhanced-loop-hook.ts.

Model Fallbacks

Stored as model.fallbacks[] in the agent config. The runtime tries them via runWithModelFallback() when the primary model returns an error.

Changelog

1.5.1 (2026-02-28)

• Fix: Auth badge now shows on ALL assistant message groups, including tool-use and autonomous loop messages — chatAuthMode passed as fallbackAuthMode to every message group renderer
• Fix: renderAuthBadge() updated to handle __mode:<mode> shorthand in addition to raw profile IDs
• Fix: OAuth-first enforcement — profile candidate list is sorted so token/oauth profiles always precede api_key, regardless of resolution order quirks
• Fix: Auth badge removed from chat controls bar (was redundant; per-message badge is more informative)
• New: "Up to Date" in gateway version header now renders as a styled pill (green dot + rounded backdrop) matching Version and Health pills
• Patches: Updated patch-auth-badge.txt and patch-pipedream-agent-switch.txt in references/v1.5.0/ to include all v1.5.1 changes

1.5.0 (2026-02-28)

• New: Auth mode badge in chat controls bar — shows OAuth / API / Fallback pill after each response via auth.status RPC reading lastGood from auth-profiles store
• New: auth.status RPC — reads lastGood from loadAuthProfileStore() and returns {profileId, mode} (oauth | api | fallback | unknown)
• New: chatAuthMode UI state — updates after each final chat event; drives the badge color/label
• Fix: Pipedream tab now refreshes when switching agents (was stuck showing previous agent's External User ID)
• Fix: Zapier tab also refreshes on agent switch (same fix)
• Patches: 2 patch files in references/v1.5.0/

1.4.0 (2026-02-23)

• New: Session History Viewer — modal overlay with full conversation history, full-text search, role filtering (All/User/Assistant/System/Tool), and pagination (100 messages per page)
• New: sessions.history RPC — reads full JSONL transcripts with search, role filtering, and offset/limit pagination
• New: Sessions tab agent filter dropdown — scope view to a single agent
• New: Sessions tab agent identity column — shows emoji + name per row
• Overhaul: Sessions tab now shows friendly display names ("Main Session", "Cron: pipedream-token-refresh") instead of raw keys (agent:main:main, agent:main:cron:cc63fdb3-...)
• Overhaul: Raw session key shown as muted subtitle under the friendly name for technical reference
• New: Empty state for agent-filtered sessions — clear message when an agent has no sessions
• New: Session count shown in store info line
• Replaced: Verbose + Label columns removed from Sessions tab, replaced by Agent column (better multi-agent UX; label was redundant with friendly name)
• Design: CSS grid layout for Sessions tab — proper column alignment using grid-template-columns with proportional widths
• Design: Agent identity resolution uses identity.name → config name → agent id fallback chain (shows "Assistant" not "Main Agent")
• Design: History button pre-selects agent filter and session in modal, loads history immediately
• Design: Raw session key shown as muted monospace subtitle for technical reference
• Fix: Chat session dropdown now shows ALL sessions (removed CHAT_SESSIONS_ACTIVE_MINUTES 120min time filter that was hiding older Discord channels and API sessions)
• Patches: 5 patch files in references/v1.4.0/

1.3.0 (2026-02-19)

• New: Edit agent inline — name, emoji, workspace always editable in Overview; single bottom Save button activates on any change; no inline Save/Cancel toggle
• New: Delete agent — 🗑️ button with inline confirmation; hidden for default agent
• New: agents-panels-cron.txt patch — Scheduler card on Cron Jobs tab now shows agent-specific job count and next-wake (n/a when no jobs assigned)
• Fix: Emoji reverting after save — agents.update now accepts an emoji param and writes - Emoji: to IDENTITY.md; previously wrote - Avatar: which was always overridden by the creation-time - Emoji: line
• Fix: Schema patch added (schema-agents.txt) — AgentsUpdateParamsSchema now includes optional emoji field
• Fix: Identity cache eviction after agent save — identity is reloaded immediately so changes are visible without refresh
• Fix: Chat dropdown emoji now uses resolveAgentEmoji() to correctly pick up IDENTITY.md emoji (not just agent.identity.emoji)
• Expanded: AGENT_EMOJIS from 60 → 103 entries across all 5 categories

1.2.1 (2026-02-19)

• Critical fix: Removed out-of-scope props and handlers from app-render.txt that referenced state not defined by this skill's app-main.txt patch — applying the previous patch would have caused TypeScript errors and runtime crashes
• Critical fix: Removed unused import from app-render.txt
• Fix: Replaced remaining as any casts in agent create handlers with typed assertions ({ ok?: boolean; error?: string } | null)

1.2.0 (2026-02-19)

• Security: Added Security & Transparency section to SKILL.md documenting credential access, external calls, patch scope, and LLM output validation
• Security: .metadata.json now explicitly declares ANTHROPIC_API_KEY/OPENAI_API_KEY as optional env vars with auth resolution order documented
• Fix: Stripped out-of-scope state fields from app-main.txt that belonged to an unrelated feature
• Hardening: agents.wizard JSON parsing now performs structural validation before accepting model output — rejects non-object, missing fields, empty strings, truncated content
• Hardening: name capped to 100 chars, emoji to 10 chars on output to prevent oversized values
• Metadata: Added capabilities block documenting auth_profile_read, external_api_calls, and source_code_patch with mitigations

1.1.0 (2026-02-18)

• Fix: AI Wizard 401 error — OAuth token was being passed as x-api-key; now falls back to api_key profile or env var
• Fix: "Agent not found in config" after creation — loadConfig now called after agents.create in both Manual and Wizard paths
• New: Emoji picker dropdown (60 emojis, 5 categories, live preview) replaces free-text emoji input
• Patches refreshed with all fixes included

⚠️ Known Gotchas

Model Dropdown Shows Only 1–3 Models

This manifests in two distinct failure modes that often alternate. Both are fixed permanently in v1.5.2 source patches. Understanding both helps if you're on an unpatched install.

Mode A — Allowlist Trap (agents.defaults.models non-empty)

Symptom: Dropdown shows a handful of models from one provider (e.g. 2 Claude variants) even though many providers have API keys configured. openclaw models list --all shows 750+ models fine.

Root cause: agents.defaults.models in openclaw.json acts as a strict allowlist inside buildAllowedModelSet() in the models.list RPC handler. Any wizard, openclaw models set <model>, or onboarding command writes a single entry there — after that, only that one provider's model is shown. The key is never auto-cleared.

Temporary fix (unpatched installs):

python3 -c "
import json, re
path = '/home/charl/.openclaw/openclaw.json'   # adjust path if needed
raw = open(path).read()
# strip JS comments, fix trailing commas, then parse
clean = re.sub(r'//.*\n', '\n', raw)
clean = re.sub(r',\s*([}\]])', r'\1', clean)
cfg = json.loads(clean)
cfg.setdefault('agents', {}).setdefault('defaults', {})['models'] = {}
open(path, 'w').write(json.dumps(cfg, indent=2))
print('done')
"
systemctl --user restart openclaw-gateway

Permanent fix (source patch — v1.5.2):
Remove buildAllowedModelSet from the models.list handler entirely. agents.defaults.models controls routing/defaults, not what appears in the UI dropdown. File: src/gateway/server-methods/models.ts.

-      const cfg = loadConfig();
-      const { allowedCatalog } = buildAllowedModelSet({
-        cfg,
-        catalog,
-        defaultProvider: DEFAULT_PROVIDER,
-      });
-      const models = allowedCatalog.length > 0 ? allowedCatalog : catalog;
+      // Always return the full catalog — agents.defaults.models is for routing,
+      // not for filtering what's visible in the UI dropdown.
+      const models = await context.loadGatewayModelCatalog();
       respond(true, { models }, undefined);

Mode B — Empty Catalog on First Gateway Boot

Symptom: Dropdown shows nothing (or only the currently-selected model as a static fallback). Happens right after a fresh systemctl restart. After a second restart it usually works. The models.list RPC takes 1000+ ms and returns { models: [] }.

Root cause: Three interacting issues:

1. loadModelCatalog() is lazy — not called until the first models.list RPC. If the gateway was busy at startup (e.g. rebuilding the Control UI, which happens on first install), the dynamic import() of the Pi SDK module may contend with other startup I/O and resolve to an empty registry.
2. When models.length === 0, modelCatalogPromise is reset to null — so every subsequent call retries, but the error is only logged once (then hasLoggedModelCatalogError suppresses all future failures). This makes the root cause invisible in logs.
3. The loadGatewayModelCatalog() wrapper had no retry — it returned [] as-is.

Permanent fix (source patches — v1.5.2):

src/gateway/server-model-catalog.ts — retry once on empty + pre-warm at startup:

export async function loadGatewayModelCatalog(): Promise<GatewayModelChoice[]> {
  const result = await loadModelCatalog({ config: loadConfig() });
  if (result.length === 0) {
    // Bust cache and retry once — handles transient startup race.
    return await loadModelCatalog({ config: loadConfig(), useCache: false });
  }
  return result;
}

export function warmModelCatalogInBackground(): void {
  loadGatewayModelCatalog().catch(() => {});
}

src/agents/model-catalog.ts — reset error-log gate on each new attempt so failures stay visible:

       modelCatalogPromise = null;
+      hasLoggedModelCatalogError = false; // allow next attempt to log

src/gateway/server.impl.ts — call warmModelCatalogInBackground() at gateway startup (after sidecars):

import { loadGatewayModelCatalog, warmModelCatalogInBackground } from "./server-model-catalog.js";
// ...inside startGateway(), after startGatewaySidecars():
warmModelCatalogInBackground();

Diagnostic Commands

# How many models does the CLI see?
openclaw models list --all | wc -l          # should be 750+

# What does the live RPC return? (needs wscat or the gateway WS client)
# Quickest check — look at the gateway log for models.list response time:
# < 100ms = hitting cache (good); > 500ms = fresh load (may be empty)
journalctl --user -u openclaw-gateway --no-pager | grep "models.list"

# Is the allowlist populated?
python3 -c "
import json, re
raw = open('/home/charl/.openclaw/openclaw.json').read()
clean = re.sub(r'//.*\n', '\n', raw)
clean = re.sub(r',\s*([}\]])', r'\1', clean)
cfg = json.loads(clean)
print('models allowlist:', cfg.get('agents',{}).get('defaults',{}).get('models',{}))
"

1.5.2 (2026-03-08)

• Permanent model dropdown fix (Mode A + Mode B): Removes buildAllowedModelSet from models.list handler — the dropdown now always shows the full Pi SDK catalog regardless of agents.defaults.models. Adds warmModelCatalogInBackground() called at gateway startup to pre-warm the catalog and prevent the empty-on-first-boot race. Adds retry in loadGatewayModelCatalog() when the first load returns empty. Resets hasLoggedModelCatalogError on each fresh attempt so failures are always logged.
• Known Gotchas section: Full root-cause writeup for both failure modes with source-level diffs and diagnostic commands.

1.0.0 (2026-02-18)

• Initial release
• Agent selector dropdown in chat header
• Per-agent session filtering (newest-first)
• New session button (+) in chat header
• Create Agent panel — Manual + AI Wizard modes
• Fallback model multi-select dropdown
• Removed duplicate "Primary Model" display from Agents overview
• agents.create / agents.update / agents.delete / agents.wizard backend methods